Handmade ceramics, average order around $48. The click numbers look great to me and reach is fine, but that's under 0.2% conversion, which is miles below what I get from Instagram. Etsy stats say the Pinterest visits bounce almost immediately. Is this just what cold Pinterest traffic looks like, or is my listing the problem?
1,800 outbound clicks to my Etsy shop last month, 3 sales
3 replies
Nine times out of ten it's the listing. Someone clicks a styled lifestyle shot and lands on a white-background product photo and feels like they got bait and switched. Make the first listing image the same image as the pin and see what happens.
0.2% is not as bad as you're treating it. Instagram people already follow you and have seen your stuff twenty times. Pinterest is discovery. Different traffic, different job, different conversion rate.
$48 ceramics is a considered purchase and Pinterest people are often planning months out - they save instead of buying. Look at your save rate, not just clicks. If saves are strong the intent is there, it's just slow, and some of those 1,800 will come back in November.
Join the conversation. Sign in to reply