I've been running both side by side for about four months on a home decor account, roughly 40k monthly views so nothing huge. Pins that go straight to the merchant get about 3x the outbound clicks but my EPC is garbage, like $0.04. The pins that land on a blog roundup get way fewer clicks and converted 11 sales last month versus 2 from the direct ones. Am I reading this wrong, or is the direct-link click just cheap traffic that was never going to buy?
Direct affiliate links on pins vs sending them to a blog post - which actually makes more?
4 replies
Direct links get clicks because the pin is basically an ad and people tap it out of curiosity. A blog post pre-qualifies - by the time someone has read three paragraphs they've decided. Your ratio looks completely normal to me.
I do the opposite of you and direct linking wins, but my niche is single-product gift stuff where nobody wants 1200 words first. It depends entirely on whether the purchase needs any convincing. Yours sounds like it does.
Worth checking that outbound clicks in Pinterest analytics and actual sessions in your own analytics are the same thing, because for me they're off by 30-40% consistently. The direct-link click advantage might be smaller than the dashboard says.
Four months is not enough to call it. Cookie windows, delayed shipping, returns clawing back commission - my numbers didn't stabilise until I had about nine months of data.
Join the conversation. Sign in to reply