I've been running two versions of basically the same pin for about six weeks. One has the keyword in the title only, the other has it in the title and worked into the description, same image, same board, published a day apart. Impressions are within maybe 8% of each other, which is noise. Starting to wonder if the description is just there for the click and the title is doing all the ranking work. Has anyone actually tested this at a scale where the answer means something?
does the keyword in the description do anything or is it all title now
4 replies
Six weeks and two pins is not a test, it's a coin flip. Pin-level variance here is enormous — I've put near-identical pins on the same board on the same afternoon and had one do 400 impressions and the other do 40,000. You'd want thirty pairs minimum before an 8% gap means anything, and even then you'd mostly be measuring the images.
Description still counts for something. I have a pin that keeps showing up for "no sew roman shade" and that exact phrase appears nowhere except the description. The title is "Window Project I Finally Finished", which is a terrible title, and it surfaces anyway. So it is definitely not title-only.
The way I've settled it for myself: the title is weighted heavier and it's also the thing a human reads, so it wins on both counts. The description is cheap insurance and it's doing work on related-pin surfaces where nobody typed a query at all. Put the phrase in the title, write the description for a person, stop A/B testing text fields. The image is doing most of the work and you're measuring the leftovers.
no idea but i'd genuinely like to see this run for six months instead of six weeks. following
Join the conversation. Sign in to reply