Cream background, black serif headline, thin rule underneath, photo at the bottom. It made most of my traffic since 2024 and by this summer it was doing maybe a third of what it used to.
Built four replacements - full-bleed photo with the headline knocked out in white, one with a hard colour block, one editorial layout built around a big number, and one that's basically the old template with a much bolder cut of the same serif. Overall impressions are up about 40%. The "basically the old one but bolder" version is the best of the four, which annoys me quite a lot.