Skip to content

I retired the template that carried me for two years. Three weeks of data

Showcase 2,669
Sarah Chen

Cream background, black serif headline, thin rule underneath, photo at the bottom. It made most of my traffic since 2024 and by this summer it was doing maybe a third of what it used to.

Built four replacements - full-bleed photo with the headline knocked out in white, one with a hard colour block, one editorial layout built around a big number, and one that's basically the old template with a much bolder cut of the same serif. Overall impressions are up about 40%. The "basically the old one but bolder" version is the best of the four, which annoys me quite a lot.

3 replies

The annoying result is the useful one. It suggests you never had template fatigue, you had a legibility problem that got worse as everything around you in the grid got louder.

Or both, and three weeks is short. Check again at ninety days - the full-bleed one will probably age differently, because photography dates faster than type does.

Did you rewrite the headlines at the same time? If you did, you've changed two things and you'll never untangle which one moved.

Join the conversation. Sign in to reply