Every "turn off auto-posting" article I can find is on the blog of a company that sells a scheduler, which makes me suspicious. The help page says you can connect feeds and it'll publish up to 200 Pins/day across all of them.
Downside I can see for myself: it takes whatever og:image and excerpt my theme spits out, so titles are my SEO titles and not pin copy, and the image is 1200x630 landscape. Is that the whole objection, or is there something structurally worse about feed-published pins?