Skip to content

Is the recipe niche genuinely cooked on Pinterest now, or is that just doomposting?

Danielle Osei

Food blogger, 4 years in. My Pinterest clicks are down roughly 55% year over year and my Google traffic is down worse. Every food blogger I know is saying some version of the same thing.

Between AI-generated recipe images flooding the feed and people getting answers without clicking, I can't tell if the niche is structurally broken or if I'm just one of the people who got hit. Anyone in food actually growing right now?

4 replies

Growing, but not the way I was three years ago. Two things changed for me.

First, generic recipes are dead. "Chicken alfredo" is unwinnable. "Chicken alfredo for one, 20 minutes, no cream" still works because the specificity is the moat.

Second, my pin images now have a human hand or a real kitchen in frame. Not because I have proof it beats the AI stuff algorithmically, but because it visibly reads as real and my saves went up when I switched.

down 60% here too since roughly june. i don't think it's you. a lot of food people got hit at the same time and nobody has a convincing explanation, including the people confidently selling explanations

I'd push back on "cooked". Saturated at the top, yes. But go look at how thin the coverage is for anything that isn't American home cooking. Regional cuisines, allergy-specific cooking, cooking for one, cooking without a specific appliance — massive demand, comparatively little decent content. I moved into low-FODMAP two years ago and it's the least competitive thing I've ever done.

The uncomfortable version: recipe blogs were never really a Pinterest business, they were a Google business that Pinterest topped up. When Google moved, the whole thing got exposed. Pinterest holding at -55% while search is worse is arguably Pinterest doing fine relative to the alternative.

Join the conversation. Sign in to reply