Skip to content

One month of AI images on a real account, and the comments I got

Showcase 743
Jenna M

Small travel blog. I tested AI hero images for a month, mostly because I couldn't afford to actually fly anywhere. Twelve pins, marked as AI.

Reach was fine. Saves were fine. What I wasn't ready for was two comments calling it out and one person messaging me to say they'd unfollowed. The pins that used my own genuinely mediocre phone photos of a train station got warmer responses than the beautiful fake ones did. I've stopped.

4 replies

The audience reaction is the story here, not the metrics. People come to Pinterest for places they might actually go. A place that doesn't exist is a bait and switch even when it's pretty.

Depends enormously on niche though. Abstract backgrounds, textures, colour fields behind text - nobody notices and nobody comments. A photorealistic shot of a real named destination that was never there is a completely different thing.

I'd be curious whether the warmth came from the imperfection rather than from the honesty. Slightly bad real photos have been outperforming polished stock for me for two years, long before any of this came up.

Join the conversation. Sign in to reply