Skip to content

Pinterest put an AI label on a photo I actually took myself

Sarah Chen

I shot it, edited it in Lightroom, healed out a power cable, cropped it. That's the whole edit. It's now carrying an AI modified label.

I don't love it, but what I actually want to know is whether that label changes anything about distribution, or whether it only matters because people can now choose to see less of that stuff in their feed. Nobody I've asked has a straight answer.

5 replies

Generative fill and content-aware tools write metadata that gets picked up on upload. A plain heal in Lightroom shouldn't, but if the file went through anything with a generative feature at any point, even an export preset you forgot about, it can carry the tag along.

As far as I can find, they have never said the label itself demotes anything. What they have said is that people can dial down generative AI content in certain categories. So the reach effect is an audience effect rather than a ranking penalty - which for you might amount to the same thing in practice, but it's worth knowing which one you're arguing with.

The categories it launched with were beauty, art, fashion and home decor, with more promised. If you're in one of those the audience filter matters a lot more than if you're writing about, say, tax software.

You can dispute it. Expect it to take a while. I had two labelled, one came off, one didn't, no explanation for the difference.

Occasional false positives are the price of the labels existing at all, and I'd still rather they exist. The feed a year ago was close to unusable in some categories.

Join the conversation. Sign in to reply