Skip to content

Printables seller: do I send Pinterest traffic to the Etsy listing or to my own site?

Questions & help Solved 1,137
Priya R

I sell budget planners and meal planning printables. About 80% of my sales are Etsy right now. I also have a Shopify store with the same products at a slightly better margin.

Sending pins to Etsy feels like building someone else's asset, but my own store converts at like a third of the rate. What's the actual right answer here or does it depend on something I'm not thinking about?

1 reply

Your own site, but not to the product page — to a free lead magnet, then sell by email.

The reason your store converts at a third of Etsy's rate isn't your store, it's the trust gap. Somebody landing cold from a pin onto an unknown Shopify store has no reviews, no buyer protection and no reason to trust you with a card. Etsy rents you that trust and charges you for it, which is a fair deal for a cold click.

So stop trying to win that fight. Pin to a genuinely useful free printable on your own site, capture the email, and sell the paid versions to people who've already downloaded something from you and found it good. My conversion on the same product went from about 0.6% cold to somewhere around 4-5% by email.

Keep pinning to Etsy too for the products where you're happy with the margin. It's not either/or. But the email list is the only part of this that's actually yours.

Join the conversation. Sign in to reply